And for the rest of you: can you guess who's who on these cakes? I already gave you a hint. (Answers at bottom.)
Say, do you suppose this Wreckerator realized that "B'day" sounds exactly like "bidet"? That just seems like a bad play, eh? (Hey, these rhymes are unintentional, Ok?)
Did you guess them all? No cheating, now!
Ok, here are your answers:
First:
Second:
Rachael G., Sarah W., & Anony M., don't stop the rock.
313 comments | Post a Comment
«Oldest ‹Older 201 – 313 of 313 Newer› Newest»I just came over here to say that #2 looked just like Charo - I am glad to see that others thought the same!
Another vote for Madonna and Charo, and the 3rd one I had pegged as Suzanne Somers.
no idea on number 1
second was Carmen Electra
third was Courtney Love
Wow...I too thought the 2nd one was Charo and had no idea on the other two. Who would have thought other people saw what I did?
Can't imagine what a cake of me would look like! :)
Swing by my Daily Gif Blog when ya have a chance...tomorrows the last day for my $50 giveaway!!
DB
The third one was easy for me. I mean, Hannah Montana's face is on every freakin' thing these days.
Toni Amos and Beyonce should sue. Seriously.
Word verification: coensphe. Short for coensphere, where the Coen Brothers live.
I'm totally on-board with Janine!
I thought the third one was Courtney Love...why a six year old would idolixe her i don't know.
Bahahahaah
I guessed Madonna, Carman Electra and Hannah Montana.
omg, she does have a lazy eye...that always freaks me out on people
I guessed
1.) Mia Farrow
2.) Charo
3.) Suzanne Somers
I was wrong. . . so sad
i thought the second one was Charo too!
I thought the Beyonce one looked like Charro haha
My guesses:
1. Madonna
2. Sophia Loren or Charro
3. Hillary Duff
I would have guessed Madonna, Panelope Cruz (I know she doesn't sing), and Barbra Streisand (which made me wonder why it was for a six year old...)
Madonna, for no other reason than the cross, Charro (dead on) and Suzanne Sommers. But why would anyone want a Suzanne Sommers cake? Or Tori Amos for that matter?
Oh my God....they killed Tori.
The sad thing is that I still kinda guessed it, mostly because of the butterflies.
I didn't get any except Hannah Montana..she is so freaky looking that cake wasn't far off lol
I also thought that #1 was Madonna, and, like one other person here, I thought #2 was Susan Lucci, though I can TOTALLY see Tawny Kitaen-(yes, I am old, too!)#3 I didn't get-I knew it was some popular young person, but the icky teeth just stumped me!!!
I was thinking Madonna, Charo and Debbie Gibson... But then I thought, "No, think current" and I got the Hannah Montana one. Glad to see I am in good company on the first two.
I guessed the first one, but had NO idea about the other two. Those were just pitiful cakes.
Without looking at the comments my guesses were:
Madonna
Charo
The shark from Jaws
I'm surprised the first two are such popular guesses. Those decorators should specialize in Madonna and Charo cakes.
Glad I wasn't the only one to think #1 was Madonna and #2 was Charo... and I had no clue for #3....
I saw Madonna, Charo, and Britney as well. Funny.
I was going with Madonna for the first cake, and it looks like I'm not the only one who thought that. Hehe.
I actually got Tori Amos, and Hannah Montana! But I thought Beyonce looked more like Charo. It's funny that I'm not the only one that thought that!!
+ 200 for those that thought #2 was Charo. I actually did guess the first one. I think that might say more about me than the cake though. Yikes.
I totally had Madonna, Charro, and Miley Cyrus.
Ok, my guesses were:
Madonna
Charo
Suzanne Somers
That was fun, but totally waaay off! :)
my guesses were
1 madonna
2 no idea
3 hannah montana (slightly given away because it was a six year old's cake)
so 1 out of 3 isn't bad!
love your blog, keep 'em coming!
Another vote for (1) Madonna and (2) Charo. But three totally had me humming Carly Simon.
I actually got the Tori Amos one right away...go figure.
Ha, I thought Madonna, Brigitte Bardot (yes, not a singer) and a rather good one of Natasha Bedingfield. Guess not :D
I got 2 out of 3! I only missed the 2nd one.
The third one actually looks a lot like Hannah Montana to me. And I am not even saying it to be mean.
I thought they were Tori Amos (yay) Charo and Suzanne Sommers! LOL
i thought madonna, charo (although i couldn't actually put her face with a name til i saw the many other posts with the same frame of mind) and then came up blank on #3.
did this post make anyone else want to take their pic to giant eagle and get their own, just for s**ts and giggles, or was that just me LOL.
I must be weird, I thought the Beyonce one looked like Reba.
I thought it was Madonna, Britney Spears, and (after staring for a minute) Hannah Montana lol
LOL. Is it safe to say that I easily guessed the last face (OMG. I ALMOST TYPED MOUTH) due to the open-mouthed...ness?
My 4 year old daughter picked Hannah Montana out in 2 seconds. lol
I was thinking Madonna, Lindsay Lohan and Courtney Love.
I got Hannah Montana right! I thought number 1 was Madonna as and 2 was Charo as well.
I love that there were so many people that thought the second cake was Charo! I did too and I was sure I was right about that one.
Courtney Love cakes is what came to mind.
Hahahaha... My god, I went with Madonna, Raquel Welch (what? she's a singer!), and Courtney Love... These are great.
So my guesses were Madonna, Ashley Tisdale and...sadly, Miley Cyrus.
Dude. Them be some crazy eyes. I would be terrified if I opened that box up expecting to see my birthday cake and instead witnessed those things glaring menacingly back at me. TERRIFIED.
I got the Hannah Montana one. The smile is what gives it a way, except the cake's smile is much creepier.
For the first, I guessed Madonna. As for the second, I had no idea. I was thinking Dolly Parton.
oh...I guessed that all three were Bono...m'bad...
I guessed Tori for the first one, but that was based solely on the butterflies...
I totally was guessing Madonna and Sophia Loren for the first two....
Funny enough, the third one looked exactely like Miley Cyrus to me. Maybe because I can't stand her and so therefore I thought the nighmarish rendition was fitting, LOL.
Is it just me, but does Tori Amos look like she knows Hank Hill?
I, thought Beyonce was Charo...
And poor little 6 year old w/Hanna Montana...she looks like she's gonna eat her...
Rebecca
Where is Tori's other hand on that cake?
Isn't the second cake really Charo?
Those teeth!!!! The horror!!!
Okay, pre-answers, I thought Beyonce was Reba.
Wrecktastic.
Janine said...
"I was thinking it was Madonna, Charo & Britney Spears. whoops"
That's exactly what I was thinking.
Like so many others, I also thought it was Madonna, Charo and Britney. But, like, mini-van smashing with an umbrella Britney.
Dude, scary. Those are all freaky cakes. Particularly the last one. Her teeth are making me especially nervous.
♥ xtine
http://stuffbyxtine.blogspot.com
I thought Madonna, Paula Abdul, and Suzanne Somers. Go figure.
I thought the second one was Dolly Parton! The third I got, but it will haunt my nightmares.
I couldn't figure out why anyone would want a Charo cake!
The middle one is DEFINITELY Charo! :D
I was convinced that the Beyonce one was Charo.
I'd sue.
I thought Madonna, Charo, and Barbra Streisand.
Yeah, I'm old.
--E
I thought it was Madonna, Hilary Duff, and then Miley. I think #1 looks more like Madonna than Tori even after seeing the picture!
I got 2/3
I thought the first one was Madonna, and the only reason I guessed Beyonce was because of the B'day, and I remembered she had an album called that.
And as for Miley Cyrus/Hannah Montana, who could forget those crazy eyes?
I guessed the Tori Amos one, but only because she's the only famous singer I could think of with long red hair and a penchant for being photographed with things like butterflies, and I guessed Hannah Montana because I couldn't think of anyone else with a huge, soul-devouring grin like that. The Beyonce cake is sheer WTF - I don't think Beyonce's own parents would have guessed that one.
I know this makes me impossibly old, but the only person I could think of that even vaguely resembles cake #1 is Cloris Leachman.
I did get the Hanna Montama... but none of the others.
Wow I cannot believe I am not the only one who guessed Madonna, Charo, Britney. I feel slightly better about it now.
Oh my god, I thought the second one was Charro.
Huh. Somehow out of those cakes I got Madonna, Mariah Carey and Suzanne Sommers. Wow.
Scary Hannah Montana teeth in a whole new light:
http://photoshopdisasters.blogspot.com/2008/03/hannah-montana-really-real-teeth.html
My daughter guessed the Hannah Montana cake, I had no idea on any of them.
I'm happy to see that I wasn't the only one who guessed Madonna and Charo for the first two!
Apparently that was the most excellent unintentional Charo cake of all time.
The last one had me stumped, but I was pretty sure it was either Suzanne Somers or Joanie Greggains...they're the same anyway, right?
I thought the Beyonce one was actually supposed to be Charro...
I TOTALLY thought the second one was Charo!
I thought either Madonna or Tori Amos for 1. I'm with you all on the Charo for 2. I thought number 3 was Kathy Griffin as a blond.
I totally thought the Hannah Montana was Suzanne Somers!
I thought Beyonce was Paula Abdul.
This post was linked on a very popular celebrity gossip community (http://community.livejournal.com/ohnotheydidnt/32750133.html) so if your site traffic has gone up dramatically I wouldn't be surprised! Personally I'm grateful. What an awesome blog!
I literally thought Beyonce was Charo. If it was a Charo cake, it wouldn't have been a wreck.
I got the Tori Amos one!! I thought they did a pretty good job, I'm definitely not that creative with icing. :/
I guessed Margaret Atwood, Charo (yep) and Vaginal Davis!!!
Hahaha! I got the first one. So good.
1. Tori Amos (awful but I think I recalled the magazine cover somehow).
2. Sofia Loren (apologies to her)
3. Courtney Love
I thought that the Hanna Montana cake was that woman from 'Medium'
Whahahaha it looks a lot a like ;)
Wow, I got them all wrong. I thought it was Madonna, Janet Jackson and Britney Spears. Yikes! I should have known about the Miley one though since the eyes and mouth are pretty dead on.
call me stupid, but i actually though the first one was a crappy attempt on cameron diaz.
the second one i thought was an old lady addicted to plastic surgery and tanning!!
but miley's was dead on. gives me the creeps. wouldnot want that served at a 6 year old's party....
Bette Midler, Reba Mcintyre and Madonna. I am really old.
I could swear the is Madonna, Charo and Suzanne Somers. There is no way that's not Chrissy Snow.
WTF Does everyone think the first on is Madonna? I knew it was Tori because I know that photo from Rolling Stone Mag...also, Madonna doesn't have red hair! AND Madonna blows.
The Miley one is HILARIOUS though. HA HA HA HA!!
The Hannah Montana cake was fairly accurate...
I thought the first one looked like Joan Rivers!
I guessed Hannah Montana, but then again, I had the "6th Birthday" thing helping me along to that conclusion.
:)
I thought Charo for the 2nd one also. For the 3rd I thought Courtney Love is who it actually looked like LOL, but thought it was probably supposed to be Britney Spears.
Linda K
Okay I love Tori & I thought Madonna... I think it's the cross necklace (where did that come from?) Beyonce's I would have NEVER guessed, and the hanna montana one looks like she's part Blade style vampire coming to rip my head off!!!!
LOL i thought the second cake of beyonce was charo! LOL cuchi-cuchi!
I know I'm late but I'm curious... Am I the only one who thought "Barbara Streisand, some chick from the 70's who's name escapes me(Olivia Newton John? Carly Simon? I don't know), and Barb again? I'm embarrassed that I love Tori so much and thought it was Streisand.
I can't believe only person besides me guessed Reba McEntire on the second cake. Charo is just not my generation but I almost guessed Kathy Griffin before I decided on Reba. But I got Madonna on the first one and Hannah on the third because the third one is actually accurate.
Meghan the Smith
Hey, I got Tori Amos right!! I'm impressed with my early 90's memory, and you should be too!
And yes, Miley Cyrus DOES have crazy eyes and chain-smoker teeth. O.o
so, if the album is "b'day," then that means that the cake actually says "happy Kim." there are no words.
Madonna, Charro, and Kathy Griffin. Lol awful...simply awful. lol xx
That's sad, i'm a huge Tori fan, I even have that magazine and I thought it was Carrot Top!
OK, my incorrect guesses were 1) that Shawn White guy who does some sport that I can't even believe is in the Olympics, 2) Charo on a bed of CDs, and 3)Patricia Arquette. Judging by the other guesses, I'd say and actual Charo cake is in order.
Okay, if this didn't say celebrity singers, I would have sworn the first one was Ms. Frizzle from the Magic School Bus!
Would you believe I managed to guess Tori Amos? I'm not sure exactly why or how... Maybe because she's my fave singer and one of the rare few with red hair.
Simply atrocious. Makes for some entertaining reading, though! I am thoroughly enjoying my tour of your blog!
I thought the 2nd and 3rd ones was Charo.
I was sure the first one was Joni Mitchell.
I guessed Hannah Montana, only b/c it said "happy 6th" but to me it totally looks like suzanne sommers!
i thought the third one was suzanne summers! looks just like her lol
the hannah montana cake was for a 6th birthday party. What could you expect?
I did though, consider madonna for all of them. Who hasn't she looked like?